When you're replacing a roof, the material you choose can affect the appearance, maintenance, lifespan, and overall cost of the project. Asphalt shingles and metal roofing are two common options, but they have different characteristics. Looking at how each material fits your home can help you make a more informed decision instead of choosing based on price alone.

​

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are a popular choice for residential roofing because they're available in a wide range of styles, colors, and price points. They're also familiar to most roofing contractors, which can make repairs and replacement relatively straightforward. Different asphalt shingles offer different levels of durability and expected lifespan. The quality of the product, installation, maintenance, and weather exposure all play a role in how the roof performs over time. For many homeowners, asphalt shingles are also an easy way to match the existing appearance of the home.

​

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is another option homeowners may consider when replacing a roof. Metal roofs can be made from different materials and installed in several styles, giving homeowners options for both appearance and performance. Metal roofing can also have a different maintenance and lifespan profile than asphalt shingles. The right choice depends on the specific product, installation, home, and what you're looking for from the roof. The initial project cost can also be different, so it's worth looking at the full scope of the installation.

​

What About Weather?

Colorado weather is an important consideration when choosing any roofing material. Hail, wind, snow, rain, sunlight, and temperature changes can all affect a roof over time. Neither material should be chosen based on one weather event alone. Instead, consider the overall performance of the product, the quality of installation, maintenance requirements, and how the material fits the home. Your contractor can also explain how the specific roofing products you're considering are designed to handle the conditions common in your area. Different products within the same material category can perform differently, so comparing the actual roofing systems is more useful than comparing only the material names.

​

Consider the Full Cost

The initial price of a roof is only one part of the decision. You'll also want to consider expected lifespan, maintenance, repairs, installation, and how often the roof may eventually need to be replaced.

A material with a higher initial cost may have different long-term expenses than a lower-cost option. Comparing the full project rather than just the price per square can give you a better understanding of what you're actually getting. Make sure estimates include the same basic scope of work when comparing them. Removal, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, cleanup, and other parts of the installation can affect the final price.

​

​